Financetoday
financialTelegram

Cash First, Then What? The Retirement Withdrawal Order That Can Backfire

Retirement·October 17, 2026

Cash First, Then What? The Retirement Withdrawal Order That Can Backfire

A reader's question is one many people ask once the paychecks stop: in what order should the money come out? The plan under discussion is a familiar layered approach. Claim Social Security first, draw on annuity income next, tap cash reserves after that, and leave the traditional IRA for last. It looks tidy on paper, and for some households it works well. But the sequence carries a timing problem that planners watch closely.

The core issue is that a traditional IRA is tax-deferred, not tax-free. Every dollar that leaves the account is taxed as ordinary income. Leaving the IRA alone while living on cash lets it keep compounding, which is the appeal. The catch is that the account does not stay untouched forever. Once a retiree reaches the age when required minimum distributions begin, the government sets a minimum amount to withdraw each year, whether or not the money is needed.

That is where the surge comes from. If the cash and taxable savings are gone and the IRA has grown large, those forced withdrawals in the 70s can stack on top of Social Security benefits and any annuity payments. Taxable income can jump sharply. More of the Social Security check may become taxable, the retiree may move into a higher bracket, and Medicare premiums can rise through income-related surcharges. Someone who looked comfortable at 65 may find the bill arriving a decade later.

Planners often suggest testing the order rather than accepting it as written. Some retirees take modest amounts from the IRA in the early years, especially in lower-income years before Social Security begins, to fill low tax brackets on purpose. Converting part of an IRA to a Roth account during those years is another option, though it creates a tax bill up front. The aim is to spread taxable income across decades instead of letting it spike at a single point.

The Social Security decision belongs in the same conversation. Each year a worker waits past full retirement age increases the monthly benefit, up to age 70. Waiting can also keep more of that check outside the tax system in the early years, because the retiree is living on other accounts. Whether the trade pays off depends on health, marital status, and how long the person expects to live.

Annuities deserve a separate look, since their role depends heavily on the product. A guaranteed income annuity can cover basic expenses regardless of market swings. Other types carry fees, surrender periods, and complicated rules. Placing an annuity ahead of cash in the sequence only makes sense after the contract terms and their tax treatment have been reviewed.

The broader takeaway is that the order of withdrawals matters less than the tax picture it produces over time. A simple list of what to spend first can hide years of rising brackets. Projecting income year by year, including required distributions, Medicare thresholds, and the taxation of benefits, usually shows where a plan bends. For households a few years from retirement, a fee-only planner or tax professional who can model these scenarios is often worth the cost. This is general information rather than personal advice, and the right sequence depends on details no article can see.

Reporting based on an external source.