Is Inflation Quietly Eating Away at a Church's $1.5 Million Gift?
Nonprofit Finance·October 30, 2026
A church sitting on a $1.5 million bequest is asking a question many nonprofits face: is the money losing ground? The congregation says the gift is large and meant to last for years, so it wants to be sure the funds are managed prudently.
The short answer is that a 3.75% rate preserves buying power only if inflation stays below that figure. When prices rise faster than the interest rate, each year's earnings buy less than the year before, even though the account balance is growing on paper.
The arithmetic is straightforward. At 3.75%, the account would earn about $56,250 in a year, before taxes or fees, if the rate holds. If inflation runs at 3%, the real return is roughly 0.75% a year. If inflation matches or exceeds 3.75%, the principal stops growing in real terms and begins to shrink. Because bank rates can change, the church should also assume the 3.75% figure is not guaranteed for the life of the gift.
Safety is the main reason to keep a large sum in a bank. Deposits are stable and easy to access, which matters if the church needs cash on short notice. The trade-off is that cash-like accounts rarely outpace inflation over long periods. Stocks and bonds have historically offered higher long-term returns, but their values move up and down, sometimes sharply.
There is also a practical issue. Standard federal deposit insurance covers up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category. A $1.5 million balance held in a single account at one bank would exceed that limit, so the church should confirm how its funds are spread and insured.
Most advisers suggest a few steps: set a target return that covers expected inflation plus the annual amount the church plans to draw, split the funds between liquid reserves and longer-term investments, and review the bequest's terms, which may limit how the money can be invested. Working with a fiduciary adviser and a written investment policy can keep those decisions consistent from one board to the next.
Reporting based on an external source.