Social Security Fixes Could Shrink Your Annual Raise
Social Security·October 26, 2026
Social Security's cost-of-living adjustment, or COLA, is the yearly increase that is meant to keep benefits in step with inflation. Each year the Social Security Administration sets the figure using the change in the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers, known as CPI-W. As the program's long-term funding gap draws more attention, lawmakers and policy groups have floated changing that formula.
The idea that gets the most discussion is switching to chained CPI, a different inflation measure that accounts for shoppers trading down to cheaper goods when prices rise. That measure has tended to run cooler than CPI-W, and estimates of the gap are often put at a fraction of a percentage point a year. That sounds small, but it compounds, so a benefit that rises a little less each year ends up noticeably lower after a decade or two.
For an individual, the effect depends largely on how long they collect. A retiree who receives benefits for 20 or 25 years would see the shortfall grow with every passing year, and because each adjustment builds on the last, the lower increases carry forward. People who claim later in life may feel less of the effect over the span of their retirement, while workers who are still years from claiming would bear more of it.
Supporters argue that chained CPI is a more accurate reflection of how people actually spend, and that a switch would help close the program's shortfall without raising payroll taxes or cutting the initial benefit formula. Critics, including many advocacy groups for older Americans, respond that seniors spend a larger share of their budgets on health care, which has often risen faster than general inflation, and that a smaller COLA would erode purchasing power for the people least able to absorb it.
For now, the existing formula stays in place. Changing it would require an act of Congress, so nothing changes for current beneficiaries unless lawmakers pass a revision. Anyone planning for retirement, though, may want to treat future raises as a possible source of uncertainty and keep an eye on the debate as it moves forward.
Reporting based on an external source.