Social Security Is Not a Ponzi Scheme, and the Funding Problem Is Real but Fixable
Retirement·November 22, 2026
Wisconsin Republican Sen. Ron Johnson has called Social Security a "scam" and urged lawmakers to shut the program down. The charge is blunt, and it revives an old comparison: a system that pays today's retirees with today's paychecks can look a lot like a Ponzi scheme, the kind of fraud that collapses once new money stops arriving. Economists and financial writers have pushed back on that comparison, and the reasons are worth laying out.
A Ponzi scheme is fraud. It promises returns that come from no real activity, pays early participants with money from later ones, and hides the fact that no underlying investment exists. Social Security differs on each point. It was created by the Social Security Act of 1935, it is funded by payroll taxes that are recorded in the program's accounts, and its benefit formulas are written into law and publicly documented. Nobody is misled about how it works, and a beneficiary's expected check is not a claim on a secret pile of money that does not exist.
The comparison does capture one real feature, though. Social Security is largely pay-as-you-go. Taxes collected from current workers mostly go to current beneficiaries, and the trust funds hold reserves built up in earlier decades that are now being drawn down. The program therefore depends on the ratio of workers to retirees and on wage growth. The program's trustees have projected that its combined trust funds could be depleted in the mid-2030s under current law. After that point, incoming taxes would still cover a large share of scheduled benefits, but not all of them. That is a genuine shortfall and a legitimate subject for debate.
It is also a solvency problem with well-known options. Lawmakers could raise or remove the cap on earnings subject to the payroll tax, adjust the full retirement age, change benefit formulas, or combine several of these. Each choice involves trade-offs, and reasonable people disagree about which to pick. None of them, however, turns the program into a fraud, and none of them makes "shut it down" a serious answer to the gap. Abolishing the program would cut off benefits for tens of millions of retirees, disabled workers, and surviving family members, many of whom have little other income.
Predictions that Social Security was about to fail have circulated since the 1930s, and many of them did not come true. Congress has repeatedly changed the program to keep it solvent, most notably with the 1983 amendments. The history suggests lawmakers tend to act when a deadline gets close, though not always early enough to avoid hard choices. The useful question for voters now is not whether Social Security is a scam, but how much of the gap to close, and who should bear the cost of closing it.
Reporting based on an external source.